Gov. Green Issues Emergency Housing Proclamation:  Analyzing Pros, Cons, and Future Implications

Gov. Green Issues Emergency Housing Proclamation: Analyzing Pros, Cons, and Future Implications

  • Audrey Alessi
  • July 25, 2023

On July 17th, 2023, Gov. Josh Green issued an emergency proclamation focused on streamlining regulatory processes for developing 50,000 housing units.

Officials believe Hawaii's housing crisis has reached a tipping point, forcing the government to take dramatic action to combat the issue. In a groundbreaking move, the state's governor has declared a housing emergency and proposed a series of measures aimed at alleviating the burden of soaring housing costs, emigration, and homelessness.

This crisis has been sparked by 6 straight years of a decline in Hawaii’s population. The community is significantly impacted by a decline in our population as essential workers are compelled to relocate to the mainland in search of a more affordable lifestyle. By suspending several state and county laws, mainly focusing on land use, historic preservation, and environmental review, the governor intends to lower regulatory barriers to building homes. 

While the actions are well-intentioned, they have sparked considerable debate over their potential impacts on the housing market and the long-term consequences they may bring. 

 

Pros of the Governor's Actions

  1. Increase Affordable Housing: The governor's plan emphasizes the construction of new housing. By incentivizing developers to focus on building more affordable properties, the housing supply for low to moderate-income individuals could see a significant boost, potentially mitigating the housing shortage. This would have a positive trickle-down effect for the Hawaii Economy such as reducing the number of important workers leaving the island due to the cost of housing. 
  2. Homelessness Reduction: The housing crisis in Hawaii has contributed to a rise in homelessness. The proposed measures aim to address this issue by providing more accessible housing options for vulnerable populations, helping to reduce the number of people living on the streets.
  3. Lower Rental Cost: If this measure is successful it will alleviate the supply and demand issue which eventually should lead to decreased rental costs. This move would likely protect tenants from excessive rent hikes, providing stability and predictability in the rental market. Lower-income families and individuals may benefit from more affordable housing options.

 

Cons of the Governor's Actions

  1. Environmental Concerns: Critics express concerns about the potential exploitation of land and environmental harms due to the suspension of regulations aimed at protecting natural and cultural resources.
  2. Lack of Transparency: The new working group Building Beyond Barriers overseeing the environmental review process is not subject to Hawaii's Sunshine Law, leading to concerns about the decision-making process being less transparent.
  3. Uncertainty for Investors: The proclamation largely focuses on owner-occupant housing. This could lead to fewer options for residents who rely on real estate investment income. While this emergency declaration intends to bring median prices down, a negative impact on property values could potentially affect the overall economy.

 

Impact on the Housing Market

The governor's actions are likely to have an impact on the housing market in Hawaii. It is no secret that prices in Hawaii have increased dramatically and that entry-level homes are in demand, but the question we must ask ourselves and being asked by our officials is: "What is the correct way to address this essential need? The governor aims to provide much-needed relief for struggling first-time home buyers and middle-class workers. According to an article from the civil beat: a recent study by the University of Hawaii Economic Research Organization found.

“Less than a third of households can afford to buy a single-family home, and less than half can afford to buy a condo, The median rental price is unaffordable to a third of households, UHERO reported.”

The focus on constructing affordable housing could increase housing options for all of these individuals and families, ultimately easing some of the pressure on the housing market. While the governor's actions represent a bold step toward addressing the housing crisis, it will be a balancing act and long-term consequences remain uncertain. The success of the proposed measures will largely depend on careful implementation and monitoring to ensure they achieve their intended goals without inadvertently causing new problems.

Moreover, it will be essential for policymakers to strike a delicate balance between providing housing stability, ensuring community transparency, and honoring important environmental concerns, all while encouraging a thriving housing market. Finding ways to stimulate housing development and ensuring affordability for residents will be critical in the coming years.

 

Bottom Line

Despite the criticisms, Gov. Green defends the emergency proclamation, stating that the housing crisis is an "existential threat" to the state, and that drastic measures are necessary to address the ongoing outmigration of residents due to unaffordable living costs.

The proclamation will be in place for one year, during which approved projects will have up to three years from approval to begin construction. The governor believes that these measures will help start to solve the housing problem and secure a better future for the state.

If you need any more information and advice regarding this policy, don’t hesitate to contact me as your real estate advisor! Additionally below is the new Housing proclamation provided by Civil Beat. 

Additional Resource: 

1. Official Housing Proclamation 

2. Civil Beat News Source 

Work With Audrey

Audrey chose a career in real estate because she realized her potential was being able to connect people to the opportunity to create wealth through real estate within the community, Audrey thrives by remembering this one thing every day. Contact Audrey today!